July 12 of 2015, teenager Tiffany Valiante went missing one night following a grad party. Her parents were immediately out looking for her. Her uncle had the misfortune of stumbling upon a police investigation on the train tracks, close to where Tiffany was last seen. He was told by investigators that a young woman had been hit by a train. He was asked to identify the body and he was shocked when it was in fact his niece.

The following day, the New Jersey Transit closed the case and labeled it as a suicide. However, there were many occurrences that lead the family to believe there may have been another reason for Tiffany to be out on the tracks that night. Her shorts were never found and her shoes were found miles away from where she was hit, despite investigators claiming Tiffany walked the tracks to her death.