This podcast examines the topics of philosophy, theology, and history from a Catholic perspective. Each podcast is 10-15 mins in length, and published (at least) weekly.
Find Catholicism in the Car on: Anchor, Spotify, Podchaser, Audible, Castbox, Radio Republic, Player FM, and Stitcher.
Also find us on:
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeCdyv4dtHnU4504ILGOQTg
Twitter: https://twitter.com/PZCatechesis
Locals: https://catholicisminthecar.locals.com/
View my blog at: https://www.parkerzurbuch.com/
Contact me by email at: parkerzurbuchcatechesis@gmail.com
All content for Catholicism in the Car is the property of Parker Zurbuch and is served directly from their servers
with no modification, redirects, or rehosting. The podcast is not affiliated with or endorsed by Podjoint in any way.
This podcast examines the topics of philosophy, theology, and history from a Catholic perspective. Each podcast is 10-15 mins in length, and published (at least) weekly.
Find Catholicism in the Car on: Anchor, Spotify, Podchaser, Audible, Castbox, Radio Republic, Player FM, and Stitcher.
Also find us on:
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeCdyv4dtHnU4504ILGOQTg
Twitter: https://twitter.com/PZCatechesis
Locals: https://catholicisminthecar.locals.com/
View my blog at: https://www.parkerzurbuch.com/
Contact me by email at: parkerzurbuchcatechesis@gmail.com
149. Communion on the Hand - from Annibale Bugnini's Memoir
Catholicism in the Car
34 minutes 58 seconds
2 years ago
149. Communion on the Hand - from Annibale Bugnini's Memoir
I made this episode before finishing the book which is the subject of this video :The Reform of the Liturgy, 1948-1975" by Archbishop Annibale Bugnini. This episode evaluates the arguments in Bugnini's Memoir IN SUPPORT of Communion in the Hand.
At "12:15" I need to find the section I reference.
You can find the free book here:
https://archive.org/details/reformofliturgy10000bugn/mode/1up?view=theater
00:00 Intro. Who was Annibale Bugnini and the Concillium?
01:20 Overview of Bugnini's Memoir. Find it on Archive.org!
02:00 How I Read Bugnini's Memoir quickly (2 months).
02:57 Communion in the Hand.
03:26 Preparing for a Debate to DEFEND Communion in the Hand. The Deus Vult Podcast.
04:21 Greatest arguments FOR and AGAINST Comminion in the Hand.
04:50 Basic History. Bugnini acknowledges that Communion in the Hand was originally done in disobedience.
06:27 Arguments in Support of Communion in the Hand
08:13 What I think is the best argument FOR Communion in the Hand
09:24 First Argument in SUPPORT - Its a Matter of Discipline
12:30 Why I recommend this book.
14:22 I don't think Bugnini was a Villian. Mass of the Ages Films.
15:23 Second Argument in SUPPORT - It's an Ancient Practice
16:19 Communion on the Tongue. The Byzantine on a Spoon.
17:12 Third Argument in SUPPORT - Children Love to Recieve on the Hand (WHAT??)
20:35 Fourth Argument in SUPPORT - A Shameful Argument Misusing Human Dignity
24:15 Fifth Argument in SUPPORT - Communion on the Hand is More Hygienic
26:05 Sixth Argument in SUPPORT - Short Priests. This one is Laughable!
28:05 Seventh Argument in SUPPORT - Appropriateness of Lay Eucharistic Ministers Giving Communion on the Hand.
28:30 Eighth Argument in SUPPORT - People Are Disobeying Us, So We Should Bless Their Disobedience. Wow.
32:00 Mention Michael Lofton @ReasonandTheology on Reviving the Practice of Excommunication.
33:51 Outro. Next Time will Give Reasons AGAINST Communion in the Hand as Listed in Bugnini's Memoir
Catholicism in the Car
This podcast examines the topics of philosophy, theology, and history from a Catholic perspective. Each podcast is 10-15 mins in length, and published (at least) weekly.
Find Catholicism in the Car on: Anchor, Spotify, Podchaser, Audible, Castbox, Radio Republic, Player FM, and Stitcher.
Also find us on:
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeCdyv4dtHnU4504ILGOQTg
Twitter: https://twitter.com/PZCatechesis
Locals: https://catholicisminthecar.locals.com/
View my blog at: https://www.parkerzurbuch.com/
Contact me by email at: parkerzurbuchcatechesis@gmail.com