In December 1996, 12-year-old Celina Mays disappeared from her bedroom in Willingboro, New Jersey. Despite a massive investigation, no arrests have ever been made, and her case remains unsolved nearly three decades later.

Family dynamics, secrets, and an alleged cult led by her aunt Certia Smith have kept this case in the spotlight. Who was responsible for Celina’s disappearance? And why has justice been so elusive?

In this episode, we uncover the details, explore the possible suspects, and revisit one of the most disturbing missing children’s cases in American history.