In this episode, Philip Gelatt, Will Battersby, April Merl, and Belle Del Sesto dive into the movies they probably shouldn’t admit they love — the chaotic comfort watches, the flawed favorites, and the cinematic oddities that refuse to let go.

They explore what makes a true “guilty pleasure,” why horror comfort films hit differently, the blurry line between bad and beloved, and how nostalgia shapes the movies we cling to. The crew also assigns each other new comfort films to watch before the next episode.

Plus: their latest recommendations in What Lurks in Our Queue.