One of my central convictions and most contrarian ideas is that the ways in which we use the terms "Islam" and "Muslim" - not to mention their various transliterated derivatives such as "Islamic" and "non-Muslim" - are inauthentic, inaccurate, misleading and divisive.
The identity and strategy of what is supposed to be a deeply faithful and universally impactful community has instead become irrelevant, redundant and insular, in large part because of the misunderstanding and misuse of these foundational terms.
I realise that these are significant claims with massive potential consequences for the way believers understand, organise and represent themselves.
But, based on my learning and experiences over the last decade in particular, I have come to see them as almost indisputable. I only say 'almost' because I always try to keep an open mind, no matter the level of my conviction. So I welcome critical responses, as long as they're shared... in good faith.
With thanks to my highly capable guest host Ali Siddiqui, this episode is a thorough exploration of the above ideas. There is always a lot more to say, which will perhaps follow in due course, if God wills. But if you can't wait...
- for a detailed exploration of all 72 nominal and verbal references to the root "aslama / yuslimu" found in revelation, see here: https://www.iqbalnasim.com/products/club-revelation/categories/2152673277
- for a related article, see here: https://www.iqbalnasim.com/blog/the-problem-with-islam-and-muslims
- read The Meaning and End of Religion: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Meaning-Religion-Wilfred-Cantwell-Smith/dp/0800624750
(0:00) Trailer
(1:07) Review of In Good Faith so far
(7:02) Isn't it too late for change?
(16:03) Transcending "us and them"
(24:10) The tyranny of doctrine
(30:17) Tackling our shared challenges
(42:32) Universal values & universal concern
(51:12) Being deeply in our context
(1:17:20) Reconciling revelation with reality
(1:34:30) Practical ideas for a better future
(1:45:11) The importance of courage