What happens when a New York election upends Jewish unity and safety—and a wave of hope collides with centuries-old fears?
This electrifying episode of In Such a Time dives deep into the shockwaves reverberating through New York’s Jewish community after Momdani’s mayoral victory. Hosts Rabbi Jonathan Jaffe and Rabbi Leora Londy tackle the complicated fallout, exploring why so many Jews—especially younger, non-Orthodox voters—prioritized values like diversity, economic justice, and inclusion over traditional concerns about Israel and antisemitism.
Listeners will be captivated by brutally honest reflections: Why did core Jewish values shift so drastically for a new generation? Is Jewish physical and emotional safety being overlooked in pursuit of broader social ideals? Rabbi Jonathan Jaffe shares candid worries about the privilege of invisibility and the chilling reality for outwardly Jewish New Yorkers, while Rabbi Leora Londy weighs the painful trade-offs between self-interest, women’s safety, and collective Jewish responsibility.
Together, the rabbis wrestle with the rise of anti-Zionism, the power of hope, and how flawed media narratives shape Jewish identity and voting patterns. They confront the tension between healing fractured communities and challenging dangerous rhetoric, never shying away from tough questions about assimilation, generational divides, and what it truly means to be a Jew—in New York and beyond.
At heart, this episode is a wake-up call: How will Jewish leaders re-engage a community redefined by skepticism, idealism, and unease? Will new hope bring cohesion, or is deeper fracture inevitable?
Timestamped Highlights Overview:
[00:00:00] – Intro to Jewish Life, Leadership, and current questions facing the community
[00:00:29] – Framing the impact of Momdani’s election & generational shifts in Jewish identity
[00:02:38] –Rabbi Leora Londy
on the erosion of Jewish unity and instilling new values
[00:04:26] – Are Jewish safety and cohesion being neglected? Alarm over political rhetoric
[00:05:21] – Why young Jews view Israel as less central, even negative; sympathy vs. critique
[00:07:17] – The tension between privilege and public Jewish vulnerability
[00:08:13] – Fear, hope, and the chilling question: Are New York Jews safe in 2025?
[00:11:14] – Voting as Jews, women, and parents: the painful calculus between competing values
[00:17:33] – Unpacking Mamdani’s worldview: anti-Zionism, scapegoating, and media influence
[00:20:43] – Why young Jews mistrust Israel and how social media warps reality
[00:24:50] – The seduction of hopeful narratives and their dark side—rewriting history and risk
[00:26:10] – Islamophobia and antisemitism: drawing boundaries, challenging false equivalence
[00:31:15] – The privileged pains of New York youth: entitlement, expectation, and disappointment
[00:37:02] – Empathy for young voters—real struggles behind the hope
[00:39:25] – Jewish leaders’ dilemma: opposition, collaboration, or listening to new voices
[00:41:00] – Parenting, education, and reclaiming Jewish identity in a fractured moment
[00:44:20] – Hanukkah vs. Purim antisemitism: assimilation’s dangerous cost
[00:47:37] – Closing wisdom: The privilege and power of joyful Jewish identity
Tune in for a riveting, no-holds-barred conversation that challenges, inspires, and demands reflection from Jews—and all New Yorkers—living in such a time.