The nerds are joined by Theo Ash to run back the gargantuan task of ranking every starting QB in the NFL, starting from the unproven youngsters like JJ McCarthy and Shedeur Sanders and working their way all the way up to the top tier, comparing Justin Herbert and Joe Burrow, discussing whether Drake Maye has cracked the Top 5 already and of course, deciding whether Patrick Mahomes or Josh Allen belongs in the No. 1 spot. Timestamps 00:00:18 - Criteria  00:07:49 - Shedeur Sanders 00:12:52 - J.J. McCarthy 00:18:04 - Tua Tagovailoa 00:26:31 - Justin Fields 00:32:18 - Tyler Shough/Spencer Rattler 00:35:55 - Geno Smith 00:45:35 - Michael Penix Jr. 00:49:59 - Cam Ward 00:54:02 - Bryce Young 00:59:01 - Jaxson Dart 01:06:46 - Trevor Lawrence 01:13:28 - Bo Nix 01:25:50 - Baker Mayfield 01:38:10 - Aaron Rodgers 01:44:41 - Daniel Jones 01:50:49 - Kyler Murray 01:56:18 - Brock Purdy 02:01:27 - Jayden Daniels 02:08:12 - Caleb Williams 02:14:50 - Jared Goff 02:21:55 - Jalen Hurts 02:34:07 - Sam Darnold 02:40:16 - C.J. Stroud 02:44:17 - Jordan Love 02:52:38 - Matthew Stafford vs. Dak Prescott 03:00:21 - Joe Burrow 03:07:14 - Drake Maye 03:15:29 - Justin Herbert 03:21:21 - Lamar Jackson 03:27:16 - Patrick Mahomes vs. Josh Allen See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.