The Pour: Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Distillery: Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, KY
Mash Bill: Undisclosed (estimated high-corn, low-rye recipe)
Proof: 90
Appearance: Warm amber with golden highlights and slow, syrupy legs.
Aroma: Sweet caramel, vanilla, and honey layered with orange zest, dried fruit, and a hint of fresh oak. Beneath the surface lies soft spice — nutmeg, cinnamon, and a whisper of leather — all hallmarks of the Buffalo Trace signature.
Palate: Medium-bodied and rounded. Notes of toffee, brown sugar, and maple open the sip, followed by dried cherries, toasted nuts, and a subtle rye spice that balances the sweetness.
Finish: Long, smooth, and gently warming — flavors of caramelized sugar, vanilla, and oak fade into a lingering sweetness that invites another sip.
The Smoke: New World Puro Especial by A.J. Fernandez
Origin: Nicaragua (Estelí)
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano
Binder: Nicaraguan Habano
Filler: Nicaraguan (Estelí-grown)
Construction: Impeccable. Firm roll with a triple cap and silky-smooth wrapper. Consistent burn and creamy draw, classic of A.J. Fernandez craftsmanship.
Appearance: Medium brown with slight oil sheen and minimal veining — elegant and understated.
Pre-light Aroma: Cocoa, sweet cedar, and a faint barnyard richness — earthy and inviting.
Flavor Profile: Medium to full-bodied. Starts with roasted nuts, espresso, and cocoa powder, then transitions into sweet cedar, earth, and a touch of black pepper. Midway through, hints of caramel and baking spice develop, echoing the bourbon’s sweetness. The final third adds a gentle mineral note and toasted oak.
Burn & Ash: Even burn, tight ash, and consistent smoke output throughout the session.
Pairing Notes
This pairing is a study in balance — Buffalo Trace’s approachable sweetness enhances the cigar’s earthy richness, while the cigar adds depth and structure to the bourbon’s mellow profile.
First Third: The cigar’s initial cocoa and espresso tones find harmony with the bourbon’s caramel and vanilla. The oak from both complements beautifully, with the bourbon’s sweetness taming the cigar’s earthy spice.
Middle Third: The New World opens up into nuttier, creamier territory, while Buffalo Trace shows more of its fruity side — cherry and orange zest come forward, brightening the smoke. Together, they create a warm, dessert-like character reminiscent of spiced chocolate and brown sugar.
Final Third: The cigar deepens with roasted coffee and a touch of black pepper. The bourbon’s gentle oak and toffee sweetness smooth the finish, leaving a lasting impression of cocoa, honey, and charred wood.
Pairing Summary
Balance: 9/10
Complexity: 8.5/10
Body Match: Excellent — both medium-bodied
Overall Experience: Exceptionally smooth and flavorful
Why It Works:
Buffalo Trace’s classic sweetness and mild spice perfectly align with the Puro Especial’s earthy, roasted core. The bourbon lifts the cigar’s darker tones, while the cigar adds complexity and character to the whiskey’s soft profile. Together, they create a seamless, indulgent pairing that highlights the strengths of both.
A timeless match that celebrates tradition, craftsmanship, and flavor harmony — a combination meant for slow sipping and steady reflection.
Become a supporter of this podcast:
https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/sticks-n-stonez--5910792/support.
Live with OneStream Live. - Live via OneStream Live #onestreamlive Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/sticks-n-stonez--5910792/support