In this True Crime Night episode of Terror Talk – True Crime • Serial Killers • Horror Movies, we dive deep into some of the most disturbing, emotional, and controversial true crime documentaries streaming right now. With a balance of serious analysis and our signature dark humor, we unpack the crimes, the psychology, and the uncomfortable truths behind these cases — and then top it off by roasting the most ridiculous one-star reviews we can find.
⚠️ Trigger Warning: This episode includes discussions of violence, murder, abuse, and sexual assault. Listener discretion is advised.
🔪 Aileen Wuornos: Queen of the Serial Killers
We revisit one of the most infamous female serial killers in American history, exploring how media narratives, trauma, and gender expectations shaped the story of Aileen Wuornos — and how documentaries continue to frame her legacy.
🧬 My Father’s the BTK Killer
What happens when the monster is your parent? We discuss the psychological toll of discovering your father is Dennis Rader, examining identity, denial, and generational trauma.
🏘️ The Perfect Neighbor
A chilling look at how obsession, entitlement, and unchecked aggression can escalate into deadly violence — and what this case reveals about warning signs we too often ignore.
🚪 Death in Apartment 603
We break down the strange circumstances, conflicting narratives, and investigative gaps that make this case linger long after the credits roll.
📱 Unknown Number: The High School Catfish
A deeply unsettling story of deception, vulnerability, and digital manipulation — and why catfishing crimes continue to thrive in online spaces.
🧩 Girl in the Picture
One of the most haunting documentaries discussed this episode, raising questions about identity, control, and the devastating impact of long-term abuse.
As therapists who specialize in understanding behavior, we examine:
Patterns of manipulation and coercive control
Trauma responses in victims and families
How documentaries shape public perception of guilt, innocence, and blame
Why some cases resonate more deeply than others
After heavy material, we lighten things up by reading and reacting to ridiculous one-star reviews of these documentaries — proving once again that sometimes the comments section is its own crime scene.