Plymouth may be remembered as the birthplace of Thanksgiving—but beneath its cobblestone streets and historic charm, the past still lingers. In this episode, Casey and Dave travel back to the 1600s to uncover the chilling hauntings of Plymouth, Massachusetts. From the restless spirits on Burial Hill—where Puritan settlers and early colonists still wander among the headstones—to the eerie echoes around Plimoth Plantation, where re-enactors and visitors report ghostly presences in the recreated village. We’ll explore the hardships of the first settlers, the lives they led, the losses they endured, and how those stories might explain why their spirits never left. Then we’ll connect it all back to the Thanksgiving season and the complicated legacy that haunts America’s “First Feast.”

🎙️ History, folklore, and ghost stories converge in this deep dive into one of New England’s oldest—and most haunted—towns.