In this wide-ranging and intellectually honest episode of The Dr. Robert E. Marx Show, Dr. Marx and Neil Haley dive deep into intermittent fasting, weight loss science, and the uncomfortable truth about medical research, pharmaceutical influence, and human gullibility.
What begins as a practical discussion about Neil’s real-world experience with intermittent fasting evolves into a broader examination of how diets work, why most fail, and why so much “research” in medicine deserves skepticism. Dr. Marx draws on decades as a surgeon, researcher, and expert witness to explain why conflicting studies exist—and why time, not headlines, is the ultimate judge of truth.
Neil shares his transition from OMAD (one meal a day) to a 16-hour fasting / 8-hour eating window.
Reports better sustainability, less bingeing, and improved body composition—despite being on testosterone replacement therapy, which increases muscle mass and appetite.
Emphasizes fat loss—not just weight loss—as the real goal.
Dr. Marx explains fat metabolism in simple terms:
Fat = triglycerides (three fatty acids + a sugar backbone).
When glycogen (stored sugar) in the liver is depleted—around 14–16 hours—the body is forced to burn fat.
This is why reducing carbohydrates, not magic diets, drives weight loss.
He cautions that intermittent fasting can temporarily raise blood lipids, which matters for people with heart disease.
Based on published consensus and clinical experience, Dr. Marx advises against intermittent fasting for:
Diabetics (especially insulin-dependent)
People with known heart disease
Pregnant women
Children and teenagers
People with immune deficiencies
Patients with certain endocrine cancer syndromes
For healthy adults, he views intermittent fasting as reasonable—but not miraculous.
Dr. Marx pulls back the curtain on medical research:
Poor control groups
Mixed populations (young vs. old, cancer vs. non-cancer)
Selective publishing (only favorable timeframes released)
Financial pressure from Big Pharma
He recounts firsthand experience uncovering “pencil-whipped” safety data, manipulated endpoints, and studies quietly buried when results turned negative.
“Time is the final peer reviewer.”
Dr. Marx strikes a balanced note:
The Good:
HIV transformed from a death sentence to a manageable disease
Major advances in cancer control
Breakthroughs in surgery and wound healing
The Bad:
Overprescription (opioids, GLP-1 drugs, osteoporosis meds)
Inflated pricing (20% added for litigation risk)
Marketing-driven diagnostics (DEXA scans, thresholds set by drug makers)
Every diet works if you stick to it.
Every diet fails when life intervenes.
Calorie balance still matters—but biology and behavior matter more.
Sustainable lifestyle change beats extreme plans.
“Every diet works. Every diet fails. Discipline is the difference.”
“Research can be massaged. Time cannot.”
“If you eliminate sugar, fat storage collapses—no magic required.”
“Big Pharma has saved millions of lives—and misled millions more.”
Intermittent fasting is a tool, not a cure-all.
Be skeptical of studies that promise certainty.
Know your own health risks before trying restrictive diets.
Sustainable change beats aggressive short-term fixes.
Question marketing—especially when money is involved.
Website: https://drrobertemarx.net
X (Twitter): https://twitter.com/remarx_facs
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100091526944108
Radio Syndication: https://amfm247.com/amfm247/
Spotify Hub: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/robert-marx
This episode reflects professional experience and informed opinion. It is not medical advice. Always consult qualified healthcare providers before making dietary or medical changes. Content reflects discussions as of December 5, 2025.