
**CONTENT WARNING: In order to discuss the events of both films, we discuss scenes of sexual violence**
Back for a bonus episode, due to popular demand we've done what none of you should probably attempt and that is watching both adaptations of Stieg Larsson's The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo - back-to-back.
The 2009 film from Niels Arden Oplev marked the arrival of Noomi Rapace and Michael Nyqvist, both of whom would go on to fairly successful Hollywood careers. Its a relatively faithful adaptation of the novel, albeit on a budget that only just elevates it above its TV movie roots.
Just a couple of years later, the same story got the Hollywood treatment under the stewardship of David Fincher. With a budget close to $100m and James Bond in the lead, surely this had to smooth off some of the book's rough edges in order to see a wide release, right?
Catherine's read the books, Neal and Ben haven't. So how will that affect their opinions of these two films, which share so much in terms of narrative, but are wildly different in style and approach?
If you're interested in the team's views on non-remake properties, you can follow us on Letterboxd:
Neal's profile - https://boxd.it/1EHhTBen's profile - https://boxd.it/1lH3J
We want your feedback, 3-word reviews and suggestions for any other films that have been remade, so find us in these places:
Follow us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Goodbadremake/
and on Twitter: twitter.com/GoodBadRemake
And get in touch here: goodbadremake@gmail.com
Music is 'Bring Me the West' by phlaala