Although Heinz Werner Schmidt’s With Rommel in the Desert focuses exclusively on the North African theatre, the roots of Rommel’s eventual defeat stretch back to the lesser-known campaign fought far to the east in Eritrea. The Battle of Keren (February to March 1941), a brutal engagement between Italian colonial forces and British Commonwealth troops, proved to be one of the decisive turning points of the entire African war.The victory at Keren ensured the collapse of Italian East Africa and brought Eritrea and the Red Sea coast under Allied control. With the fall of Keren, the Allies secured the vital Red Sea supply line, the artery that connected Britain, India, and the Middle East with the Suez Canal and the Egyptian front. This strategic success meant that, by the time Rommel and his Afrika Korps landed in Libya in early 1941, the British could safely reinforce and resupply their armies in Egypt without fear of Axis naval or air interference from East Africa.In contrast, the Axis powers lost any hope of linking their forces across Africa or threatening the Suez from the south. The defeat in Eritrea crippled Italy’s colonial ambitions and left Rommel’s forces in North Africa isolated and dependent on long, vulnerable Mediterranean supply lines, which the Royal Navy and Allied air forces steadily choked.Thus, while Schmidt’s account vividly captures Rommel’s tactical brilliance and battlefield hardships, it is the quiet triumph at Keren and the securing of Eritrea that laid the strategic groundwork for the eventual collapse of the German Italian position in North Africa. The Eritrean Front, often overlooked, was the hidden victory that made Rommel’s defeat inevitable long before the sands of El Alamein were soaked with battle.