This week, Amber covers the near fatal hazing of Danny Santulli at University of Missouri's Phi Gamma Delta fraternity. Then, Naomi covers the incredulous true story of a man who spent decades pretending to be other people, in an attempt to stay young forever? For this episode, Amber was drinking Hearsay – Red Blend from Santa Barbara County Amber's Sources: House of Horrors: Secrets of College Greek Life Episode 1 Parents of freshman permanently impaired in hazing incident praise new l...

This week, Naomi covers the double homicide of a man and his wife killed by what the press described as “a woman scorned”. Then Amber tells the story of a dad-turned-cult leader to a group of college friends in Yonkers, New York. Amber was drinking a pinot from Johan Vineyards in Willamette Valley. Naomi's sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betty_Broderick https://murderpedia.org/female.B/b/broderick-betty.htm https://murderpedia.org/female.B/b/broderick-betty.htm Amber's sources: Stole ...

In this episode, Amber covers a high school catfishing story where a teen and her boyfriend face persistent harassment from an unknown number. Then, Naomi covers the harrowing rescue of 12 boys and their coach from the depths of a dangerous cave, that captivated the entire world. For this episode, Amber was drinking a lime San Pellegrino. Amber's Sources: Unknown Number Documentary 10 Jaw-Dropping Details 'Unknown Number' Didn't Include About Owen and Lauryn's Cyberbullying Case ‘Unknow...

This week, Naomi covers another notorious murder from the 80’s that inspired a made for tv movie: the murder of a beloved daughter whose death shook an entire community. Then Amber covers the making of the 1981 movie, Roar which was one of Hollywood's most dangerous and chaotic projects. For this episode, Amber was drinking Bebame Red from El Dorando County CA Naomi's Sources: https://murderpedia.org/female.P/p/protti-bernadette.htm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Kirsten_Costas...

This week, Amber covers the attempted murder of Ashley Freeman and Michael Grinnan. Ashley and Michael were college sweethearts and out for a night drive, when things went horribly wrong. Then, Naomi covers a mass killing in Melbourne, Australia that shocked the whole nation. For this episode, Amber was drinking Ben Ami, a red blend from California. Amber's Sources: Massillon murder suspect has decades-long criminal history Massillon man admits to killing two women, gets life term Ash...

This week, Naomi covers one of the most infamous murder trials in modern history, one of the first to be televised in real time. Then, Amber tells the story of a newly divorced dad, on his first vacation without his family, and a sight seeing excursion gone horribly wrong. Amber was drinking Sleight of Hand Cellars, a Columbia Valley Red. Naomi's sources: https://www.cbsnews.com/pamela-smart-accepts-responsibility-husbands-murder-first-time https://www.governor.nh.gov/governor-ayotte-pardon-r...

Amber and Naomi are taking a much needed and unprecedented hiatus. Don't worry! We'll be back in no time! In the meantime, here's another old favorite of ours, Episode 146, originally published on July 30th, 2023. This week, Naomi covers the tragic murder that led to the Nikki Kuhnhausen Act, removing the “gay & trans panic defense” in Washington State as justification for murder. Then Amber covers The Harvey's Resort Hotel bombing. In August of 1980, what appeared to be a delivery from ...

Amber and Naomi are taking a much needed and unprecedented hiatus. Don't worry! We'll be back in no time! In the meantime, enjoy another peek behind the paywall with Bonus Episode 19, originally published on Patreon September 2024. In this episode, Amber covers the murder of Mark Schwebes. In 1996, beloved Riverdale High School band teacher, Mark Schwebes was gunned down on his front porch. Then, Naomi recalls the events of the week in 1999 that the World Trade Organization held their ...

Amber and Naomi are taking a much needed and unprecedented hiatus. Don't worry! We'll be back in no time! In the meantime, enjoy an old favorite or ours, Episode 118, originally published on January 15th, 2023. This week, Naomi takes us back to the home of the Aggies when Texas A&M had a knife-wielding serial raper on campus, and the story of how he was finally brought to justice. Then Amber covers the story of an online cult that ended in murder. This week, both gals were drinking water....

Amber and Naomi are taking a much needed and unprecedented hiatus. Don't worry! We'll be back in no time! In the meantime, enjoy a peak behind the paywall with Bonus Episode 3, originally published on Patreon May 2023. On this bonus episode, Amber tells the story of the brutal murder of young mother, Nikki Whitehead. Then, Naomi covers the strange story of the death of Carla Jean Shaffer on the beautiful Orcas Island, off the coast of Washington State, where many local residents believe a dan...

This week, Naomi covers a case from 1989 that the press dubbed “The Fatal Attraction Murder”. Then, Amber takes us on a ride along with the P.I. moms who were looking for an interesting job that would work with their busy lives and got way more than they bargained for. Amber was drinking water...again....it happens. Naomi's sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carolyn_Warmus https://murderpedia.org/female.W/w/warmus-carolyn.htm https://allthatsinteresting.com/carolyn-warmus https://wegotthi...

This week, Amber covers the murder of Molly Watson, gunned down just days before her wedding. Then, Naomi covers the life and death of a woman who built an empire, and many say a cult, preaching that God’s will is thinness. Amber was drinking water....we recorded at noon. Amber's sources: The Shadows of Death - S3 E2 “A Double Life” Bride murdered 2 days before wedding reveals groom's secret double life - ABC News Bride-to-Be Was 2 Days from Disney-Themed Wedding — Then She Was Shot, Exposing...

This week, Naomi covers what some believe to be the most extreme and shocking case of Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy ever recorded. Then Amber takes us on an adventure in the skies with a man who made his childhood dream come true in a most unorthodox way. This episode, Amber was drinking Kirkland Signature Rose Prosecco. Naomi's sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marybeth_Tinning https://murderpedia.org/female.T/t/tinning-marybeth.htm Amber's sources: Wikipedia — “Lawnchair Larry flight” ...

This week Amber covers the devastating murders of Kaylee Ann Brock and Julie Ann Mooney committed by Kiernan Brown. Then, Naomi tells the twisting tale of the death of a Houston socialite that inspired a made for tv movie. Amber's Sources: ‘I wish I could change it’: Killer apologizes for murdering two women with hammer | Trending | fox13memphis.com Families of Kiernan Brown's victims speak during his sentencing Invisible Choir Episode 242 “The One With Demons” Naomi's Sources: https://en.wik...

This week, Naomi covers a case of obsession that turned into murder when a young woman refused to be rejected. Then Amber covers a 16th birthday party that got completely out of control. Naomi's Sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Ryan_Poston https://www.dmefuneral.com/obituaries/Ryan-Carter-Poston?obId=4462995 https://www.eonline.com//how-the-evidence-piled-up-against-shayna-hubers https://www.aetv.com/real-crime/ryan-poston-murder https://www.wcpo.com/news/sha...

This week, Amber covers the murder of Marise Chiverella; a cold case that went unsolved for 58 years. Then, Naomi goes down the Sovereign Citizen rabbit hole while covering a case of suicide by cop. Amber's Sources: Murder of Marise Chiverella - Wikipedia Marise Chiverella: Cold case murder of 9-year-old Pennsylvania girl solved nearly 58 years later | CNN How a Teenager Solved a 57-Year Cold Case Police Called Impossible Naomi's Sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

This week, Naomi covers the decades old unsolved murder of an entire family in the Siskiyou Mountains in southern Oregon. Then Amber covers the story of raining blobs. In August 1994, the town of Oakville, Washington, experienced a bizarre phenomenon: it rained blobs of a clear, gelatinous substance Naomi's Sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowden_family_murders https://www.strangeoutdoors.com/true-crime-in-the-outdoors/cowden-murders https://kobi5.com/news/unsolved-so-oregon-mystery-in-...

This week, Amber covers the murder of Rhonda Chantay Blankenship. Rhonda who went by Chantay, never returned home after her evening walk. Her body was later found in an abandoned house. Then, Naomi tells the story of a woman who skyrocketed to fame in the health and wellness industry, only to be revealed as the worst kind of deceiver. For this episode, Amber was drinking a raspberry hard seltzer. Amber's Sources: Dateline Podcast - Ep 250 March 4, 2025 https://www.tdcaa.com/journa...

This week, Naomi covers the life of a woman who terrorized everyone in her orbit, some of them to their death. Then Amber covers the February 2013 disastrous voyage of the Carnival Triumph cruise ship. For this episode, Amber was drinking a lime hard seltzer. Naomi's Sources; If You Tell: A True Story of Murder, Family Secrets and the Unbreakable Bond of Sisterhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelle_Knotek Amber's Sources: Trainwreck - Poop Cruise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carn...

This week Amber tells the story of Judith Therianos. 52-year-old Judy was visiting a friend who was sick, when she went missing. Then, Naomi takes us deep into the wilderness of northern Maine and one of the most convincing accounts of alien abduction on record. For this episode, Amber was drinking American Vintage Red Blend from CA Amber's Sources: The Murder Tapes S1 E3 Jane Does Murder of Judith Therianos by Timothy Frederick Johnson detailed on The Murder Tapes So...