Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from December 4. Eddie gets a call from his son’s principal and Reed is on pins and needles waiting to hear what happened. The story involves Kick Me signs, actual kicking, and a level of accountability that somehow makes Reed laugh even harder. From there, Reed spends the show backpedaling after saying a few things about his girlfriend that he probably shouldn’t have, especially when relationships and “the look” come up, forcing Eddie to step in and take the shovel away. Normal or Nope covers Venmo stalking, green bubble dating drama, made-up arguments you invent in your head, and bathroom drawer snooping. Plus, the guys spiral into CIA talk, Mandela Effects, and how Eddie "Spoiled" Christmas.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from December 3. Reed gives Eddie grief for ditching work to skate with Santa, but Eddie fires back—he helped raise over $13,000 for Make-A-Wish Wisconsin, and the Grinch absolutely crushed it. Reed’s locked in on the Gameboy Lego under the Kissmas Tree, while Karli’s wrapping skills have everyone hyped for gift time. Hayley Tenpas stops by for Price Is Right: Christmas Edition, where Eddie dominates and Hayley celebrates just getting on the board. Plus, a Thanksgiving prank that went too far, a study linking drinking when you're younger to making more money later, and a woman was charged for picking up a $20 bill.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from December 2. Eddie dips out early to maybe go skating with Santa, which means Biff jumps in and chaos immediately follows. The crew debates whether anyone is truly safe from Cyber Monday, especially if beef sticks are involved, and Reed drops an “unfun” Home Alone theory that Biff and Eddie absolutely refuse to accept. Hot Take Tuesday hits with Biff’s first appearance in the hot seat, including why skipping a line is priceless and why every hot take is just complaining about accountability. Plus, a dumb criminal burns down his own house after a Thanksgiving argument, Reed’s mind is blown by car crash testing facts, heated toilet seats enter the chat, and Reed celebrates National Giving Day by admitting he doesn’t want to share anything.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from December 1. Reed is already checked out and filing everything under “future problem” while Eddie points out that most Wisconsin cities sound like bird calls. The guys try to recover from the holiday, argue over the greatest Christmas songs of all time, and learn that saying “uhh” too much might mean your brain is breaking. Things take a turn when they get into mind capturing, cryogenically freezing loved ones, and a guy who woke up with 87 thousand dollars in his bank account thanks to a glitch. Add in rising prices, football trash talk in Packers territory, and Reed’s reminder that honesty never paid his bills, and you’ve got a very normal afternoon.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 28. Reed is still spiraling after the Lions wrecked his Thanksgiving while Eddie celebrates Victory Friday, and things only get worse when a Top 5 superpower list leaves Reed with zero points and a lot of opinions. Bandle goes sideways once Karli spots them playing without her and joins in, immediately showing everyone up. Listeners share the trashiest things their families did at Thanksgiving, and Eddie fires off nonstop dad jokes that push Reed right to the edge.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 26. Reed kicks things off by making a wild Packers bet with the general manager, nearly running someone over on his way in, and dropping calorie math no one needed before Thanksgiving, while Eddie admits he doesn’t want to do anything today. Biff jumps in for Cap or No Cap Thanksgiving edition and absolutely crushes Eddie, they compare what they’re thankful for, debate the “right” time to eat Thanksgiving dinner, hype Martha Stewart, and end with Reed’s fun adjacent fact about Columbus mistaking manatees for mermaids.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 25. Reed finally returns and Eddie swears he didn’t miss him. They argue about how much underwear you actually pack for Mexico, Eddie tries to pass off “friendship” as Reed’s birthday gift, and Karli’s one note name that tune game turns into a total Reed sweep. Reed drops a story about a woman who supposedly came back to life right before cremation, and Eddie absolutely unravels. Plus their Top 5s, Thanksgiving traditions, and Eddie’s never ending Elfster disaster.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 20. Reed is insisting he’s not sick for the third day in a row, and Eddie is absolutely done pretending. Eddie swears he was patient zero, which is how he knows Reed is definitely sick, even as Reed digs his heels in and calls it “overusing his voice.” They break down Heinz’s new squeezable gravy, argue over whether it’s genius or garbage, and give away Weird Al tickets with Name That Tune Polka edition. They ask what you wish you had more of besides time and money, roast each other’s answers, and then dive into a Normal or Nope that somehow includes toe-licking dogs, peanut-butter-and-pickles, and backup situationships. Plus, Reed’s new jacket gets exposed, cold weather hunger gets investigated, and the GIF vs JIF fight nearly ends the show.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 19. Reed announces that raccoons are evolving to look cuter, and Eddie wants nothing to do with it. They argue about whether raccoons should be pets, Reed stresses about resort ice cubes now that his passport arrived, and Biff jumps in to defend Swifties after Reed calls them a cult. Eddie sweats through a conversation about shopping with his wife, the dumb criminal of the day fakes a carjacking to avoid it, and the guys take on the viral “green flag apartment” list before Biff and Eddie face off in a mental strength test.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 18. Reed tries to declare today the first snow of the year, Eddie refuses to let that slide, and it turns into Reed admitting he drives defensively just to avoid people like Eddie flipping him off. They argue Midwest weather, Reed’s ideal three-day snow schedule, and why Mississippi humidity was a personal attack. They joke about launching a Booze Busters show while debunking the alcohol “facts” everyone repeats. National Princess Day turns into a serious Jasmine vs Peach showdown, and Hot Take Tuesday brings tipping debates and scary movies that just aren’t scary anymore. Then comes the Taylor Swift hot take: she isn’t overrated, she’s just over discussed. Eddie agrees, Reed says he can’t knock the hustle, and Biff apparently needs to chill. They wrap with sleep habits, the viral potato-bed trend Eddie thinks sounds ridiculous, and a quick chat about why crypto still feels like a scam.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 17. Reed’s voice is hanging on by a thread while Eddie feels great and immediately starts giving him a hard time. They give away Weird Al tickets with Polka Name That Tune, Reed admits he’s the one leaving motivational stickers on Eddie’s desk, and Eddie loses a dollar trying to guess the top puppy names of the year. They hit National Un-Friend Day, break down a billionaire’s odd dating advice, debate whether money can buy happiness, and wrap it all with Powerball talk and Eddie rubbing in the Lions loss.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 14. Reed walks in ready for Eddie to roast his outfit, but instead they end up arguing about whether anyone can actually have a Rock Paper Scissors strategy. They jump from tattoo dreams to saying goodbye to the penny, which Eddie’s kid is taking harder than expected. The Top 5 Thanksgiving desserts list sends Reed spiraling over pumpkin cookies, Karli swoops in to win Bandle again, Reed shares a comet update Eddie refuses to believe, and the guys finish strong by celebrating the fact that they solved a UCLA math problem that 25 percent of freshmen couldn’t.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 13. Reed shows up in another full outfit picked by his girlfriend, and Eddie is convinced we’re watching a full makeover unfold in real time. Reed swears nothing is changing, but between the new clothes and the email saying his passport is finally on the way, Eddie says the “New Reed Era” is officially here. They argue over whether Canada counts as a foreign country, Reed talks about wanting a drippy pizza slice tattoo, and Eddie jokes he should probably check with his girlfriend before committing. They get into claimed spots around the house, Biff and Karli stop in for a simple but brutally honest friend test, and then  Reed and Eddie dream out loud about what they’d do with a trillion dollars, since Elon Musk is on track to be the worlds first trillionare. Plus, a new round of Normal or Nope brings cold leftovers, three star reviews, and the great grape sampling debate.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 12. Reed is trying to act like nothing has changed after everyone gave him grief about his new look, but Eddie says he’s out here trying to blend in like a chameleon. Reed’s mom keeps texting Eddie for updates and asking for photos, which only proves she might secretly be on Team Eddie. They settle into a very Wednesday mood and take on the great pizza drink debate, agreeing that whatever you choose, water comes in dead last. The big topic is the Thanksgiving blowup that has everyone choosing sides: he won NFL tickets for Thanksgiving Day, she’s hosting 20 people, and neither one is budging. They break it down from every angle. From there they end up talking about Target’s forced friendliness rules, Eddie’s kid having a bit of an attitude, cars getting too smart for their own good, and Reed once again trying to convince everyone an alien mothership might be real.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 11. Reed walks in with a brand new look, and Eddie points out his new hair, new shirt, no holes in his jeans, and apparently none of it was Reed’s idea. From there they dive into a stat that blows Reed’s mind about swallowing pills, then jump into the Top 5 highest earning dead celebrities of 2025 where Eddie gets three out of five right with a little help from Reed. Reed breaks down his YouTube TV conspiracy after missing the game, and Hot Take Tuesday brings the chaos with Home Alone arguments, phone battery judgments, college being a scam, and whether ghosting is rude or just efficient. Eddie also talks through his possible eye surgery, which leads to the wild story of a guy who started seeing boobs everywhere.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 7. Eddie is out again today, so Biff jumps in and the Friday chaos starts early. Reed rants about GTA 6 being delayed again after he bought a brand new Xbox for it, and Biff supports his crash out. Karli jumps in for a tight game of Cap or No Cap. Reed battles the Top 5 most popular sports mascots list Biff gives him and insists no one on Earth could guess these mascots. Biff breaks down the casino partner question, and in dream theater Reed reveals a dream he had where Eddie accidentally drops an F bomb live on the air. It’s a full Friday wing-it-and-hope-for-the-best kind of show.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 6th! Eddie’s out with a sick kiddo,so Karli steps in to keep Reed in check. Reed admits that cops make him nervous even when he’s done nothing wrong, and after hearing an FBI agent reveal the three trick questions police use during traffic stops, he’s convinced he’d end up in jail  for murder by accident. Plus, Karli admits she’s about to host Thanksgiving for the first time and is already stressed, they dive into a round of “Normal or Nope, and Reed discovers how often we’re probably getting scammed without even realizing it.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 5th. The studio smells like Christmas...well, at least to Reed, because Eddie’s convinced he might be dying after realizing he can barely smell the baked cinnamon apple Febreze. The guys dive into social rules that make no sense, like making your bed, small talk, and hugs before playing their new game “We Can All Agree… Right? Wrong,” where Reed tries to play devils advocate over loud chewers, black licorice, and refilled gastanks after borrowing a car. They also debate shower routines, brainstorm a new invention after learning about Butterball’s hosting pants, and wrap things up with Reed’s plan to make moon water under the full moon.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 5th. Reed’s in a food spiral after a week of bad eating, and Eddie’s not about to listen to a skinnier guy complain about feeling fat. They get into Tom Brady cloning his dog, some truly creepy things women have said or done to them, and the unsettling idea that Walmart might actually be spying on shoppers. Then it’s Hot Take Tuesday where Reed insists soup doesn’t count as a meal, Eddie surprises everyone by making peace with early Christmas season, and somehow they both defend a guy who woke up to $87,000 in his bank account.

Listen back to Afternoons with Reed and Eddie from November 3rd. Reed was not handling his football Sunday well, but Eddie was thriving after a Bears win. The guys celebrated National Sandwich Day with talk of their favorite sandwiches and Reed’s dream of having one named after him. Reed tested Eddie and Karli's music skills with Name That Tune: Piano Edition, shared the latest words added to the banned list, and ended up debating whether we’re even living in a real world at all.