Auston Matthews sets a new franchise record for the Toronto Maple Leafs, surpassing Mats Sundin with a milestone goal-scoring night, but defensive breakdowns continue to haunt the team. David Morassutti and Jose Taboada break down Matthews' historic achievement, the brewing legacy debate among Leafs legends, and the troubling trend of third-period collapses. Dave and Jose look at what went wrong for the Leafs against the New York Islanders, especially another tough night for Morgan Rielly. The episode also touches on Budweiser's unique tribute to Matthews’ franchise record and the fallout from another Team Canada’s World Juniors disappointment.

The Toronto Maple Leafs roar back from a 4-1 deficit, led by Auston Matthews’ vintage four-point night and clutch hat trick against the Winnipeg Jets. Is the captain recapturing his MVP form just in time for a playoff push? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down the team’s dramatic rally which was led by Matthews’ electrifying play, Dennis Hildeby’s key saves in relief, and Troy Stetcher’s steady blue line presence—all while closing the gap in the Eastern Conference wild card race. They also break down Matthews’ chase of Mats Sundin’s franchise goal record, the impact of Stetcher’s ice time boost, and Hildeby’s confidence-inspiring goaltending. The episode explores the Leafs’ revived power play, evolving line chemistry with Max Domi, and the gritty change in attitude post-holiday break.

The Toronto Maple Leafs prevail over the New Jersey Devils with a 4-0 win, despite missing Auston Matthews, William Nylander, Chris Tanev, and Dakota Joshua. Joseph Woll’s stellar shutout sparks questions: Is this grinding, team-first style the winning formula for Craig Berube’s squad? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down how role players like Bobby McMann and Nick Robertson seized the moment and stepped up in the absence of star power. The hosts spotlight special teams success, defensive adjustments, and recent injury updates for key Leafs. Standings impact, power play revival, and Berube’s “keep it simple” approach are all front and center. Plus, test your Leafs knowledge with 2025 team trivia and find out which trade deadline moves and goalie performances defined the Leafs’ season.

The Toronto Maple Leafs face adversity as injuries to Chris Tanev, William Nylander, Auston Matthews, and Dakota Joshua threaten their lineup ahead of a pivotal clash with the New Jersey Devils. Can the Leafs’ shorthanded roster hold strong and end 2025 on a high note, or will New Jersey’s speed and Jack Hughes’ firepower prove too much? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down the latest Leafs roster updates, highlight Matthew Knies’ recent surge, and examine key strategies for countering the Devils’ top lines. The hosts debate lineup decisions, power play adjustments, and special teams performance, all while raising questions about long-term player health and playoff positioning.

The Toronto Maple Leafs revive their power play with holiday magic—can this spark a push up the standings? Auston Matthews finds his scoring touch while Matthew Knies and Nick Robertson step up as secondary threats. The Leafs split their post-Christmas series with an offensive outburst against the Ottawa Senators and a gritty overtime loss to the Detroit Red Wings. Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down power play adjustments, the impact of William Nylander’s injury, and Steve Sullivan’s promotion. They also give their thoughts on what they've seen from Canada at the World Juniors, and how Craig Berube can push the Leafs toward real consistency.

The Toronto Maple Leafs kick off the post-Mark Savard era with a victory over the Pittsburgh Penguins, snapping a three-game losing streak. Can this finally be the performance that sparks a turnaround? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti look at what allowed the Leafs to come out on top, and Brad Treliving’s comments about Craig Berube's future and his desire to add to the roster with key additions. To end the show, Mike and Dave provide their Christmas Wishlist.

The Toronto Maple Leafs shake up their coaching staff, firing assistant coach Mark Savard as the NHL’s worst power play stalls. Can a bench change ignite a second-half surge, or are deeper issues plaguing the Leafs’ playoff hopes? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti unpack the ramifications of Savard’s exit, questioning if removing the power play coach is enough when problems persist at 5-on-5 and in the defensive zone. The hosts analyze the team’s lack of urgency, leadership challenges under Craig Berube, and speculation around management’s next moves. With the pressure mounting ahead of a pivotal matchup against the Pittsburgh Penguins.

The Toronto Maple Leafs spiral to last place in the Atlantic Division after back-to-back losses to the Nashville Predators and Dallas Stars. With star players stuck in a scoring drought, questions mount about whether head coach Craig Berube’s days are numbered as the team’s struggles hit a boiling point. Are the Leafs quitting on their coach—or themselves? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti dissect Toronto’s concerning lack of urgency, faded offensive firepower from stars like Auston Matthews and John Tavares, and the team's apparent mental collapse. The hosts spotlight management’s looming decisions, including possible roster shuffles, coaching changes, or even a reset during the holiday break. With the Leafs facing the Pittsburgh Penguins and growing fan frustration, is it time for a shake-up to save the season?

The Toronto Maple Leafs unravel in lifeless shutout loss to Washington Capitals. Is Craig Berube running out of answers as urgency and passion vanish from the locker room? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti dissect the Leafs’ troubling 4-0 defeat, spotlighting the lackluster performance from stars like Auston Matthews and William Nylander, defensive breakdowns, and the power play’s ongoing collapse. Key takeaways include Craig Berube’s candid postgame comments, questions on leadership, and whether the Leafs’ core is tuning out its coach. With goaltender Dennis Hildeby as the lone bright spot and fan apathy rising—reflected in rare unsold Scotiabank Arena seats—and a weekend back-to-back that will once again test this team.

The Toronto Maple Leafs’ playoff hopes hang in the balance as Auston Matthews faces mounting criticism and looks to prove the doubters wrong against the Washington Capitals. Can Matthews reignite his scoring touch and spark a crucial Leafs turnaround? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down the lineup for the Capitals and what the Leafs will be in store for. Mike and Dave also look at the Athletic’s latest trade board to look at which Leafs players made it on the list and who could be joining them down the road.

The Toronto Maple Leafs escape with a dramatic comeback win on Joe Bowen Appreciation Night, but concerns continue to linger about their slow starts and performance from the top players. Down to the Chicago Blackhawks after a sluggish first 50 minutes, the Leafs rallied with goals from Oliver Ekman-Larsson, Auston Matthews, and Dakota Joshua to clinch a 3-2 victory. Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down the highs and lows, praising Joseph Woll’s steady goaltending. The hosts spotlight Auston Matthews’ struggles, citing alarming stats about his reduced play speed and rush offence, and debate whether his explosiveness and MVP-calibre play can return.

The Toronto Maple Leafs salute legendary broadcaster Joe Bowen on a night packed with nostalgia and anticipation. As Joseph Woll returns to the crease, can the Leafs snap out of their recent slump and reclaim their winning form? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti relive classic "Holy Mackinac" moments, discuss Bowen’s unique impact on hockey culture, and break down what his retirement means for generations of Leafs fans. With Connor Bedard sidelined, the struggling Chicago Blackhawks bring a depleted lineup to Scotiabank Arena. Key discussion points include Frank Nazar's top-line challenge, Tyler Bertuzzi’s resurgence, and how Woll’s return could bring much-needed stability for the Leafs. The hosts spotlight lineup updates, injury news on Anthony Stolarz and Chris Tanev, and share three keys the Maple Leafs must execute for a bounce-back win.

Get ad-free episodes, access to our members-only Discord community, exclusive shows, and more by joining the Everydayer Club. The free daily show isn't going anywhere—this is just for those who want to take it to the next level. Learn more and sign up at

The Toronto Maple Leafs unravelled against the Edmonton Oilers as Connor McDavid outshone Auston Matthews in a marquee Saturday night showdown. Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti debate the ramifications of the Leafs' lacklustre effort, calling out Toronto's core for falling short just as the Oilers’ stars seize the spotlight. The hosts dissect defensive lapses, William Nylander’s illness, and whether reinforcements like Joseph Woll and Chris Tanev could help right the ship ahead of the matchup with the Chicago Blackhawks. The conversation heats up with a breakdown of the Quinn Hughes blockbuster trade to the Minnesota Wild and what it signals for the future of NHL roster management. Should the Maple Leafs have moved a core player earlier, mirroring Vancouver’s bold decision?

The Toronto Maple Leafs suffer a tough overtime loss against the San Jose Sharks, but the bigger blow comes from Oliver Ekman-Larsson’s injury as the blue line depth continues to thin. Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti dive into the loss to the Sharks, how William Nylander responded to his demotion and Auston Matthews’ defensive struggles. They also look at another stellar night for Dennis Hildeby, preview the looming challenge as Connor McDavid and the Edmonton Oilers come to town, and the current state of the Maple Leafs’ defence, exploring the impact of Ekman-Larsson’s absence, plus injuries to Chris Tanev and Brandon Carlo.

The Toronto Maple Leafs shake up their lines as Coach Craig Berube sends a message to William Nylander, dropping him to the third line after a scoring slump. Is this the spark Nylander needs to reignite his season? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti analyze Berube’s bold move, Nylander’s recent lack of production, and what it means for the Leafs’ offence as they enter a marquee week featuring matchups against Macklin Celebrini. Mike and Dave discuss the possibility of the Leafs being a potential landing spot for superstar defenseman Quinn Hughes. The hosts also preview the Maple Leafs vs. San Jose Sharks clash, spotlighting Celebrini’s sensational rookie year and key players to watch.

Toronto Maple Leafs forward Bobby McMahon received a one-game suspension for high-sticking, raising questions about the NHL's Department of Player Safety’s consistency. Did league officials set a new precedent? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down the suspension, compare it to past cases and spotlight calls for greater transparency in NHL rulings. They look at Ben Danford’s strong chances to make Team Canada’s World Junior roster. To end the show, Mike and Dave discuss a potential option to address the team’s ongoing power play struggles and whether trade possibilities are emerging with Toronto’s goaltending depth.

The Toronto Maple Leafs blank the Tampa Bay Lightning as Dennis Hildeby earns his first career shutout. Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down Toronto’s 2-0 victory, spotlighting Hildeby’s poised netminding, which should calm nerves about the team's goaltending situation. They also discuss the Leafs' physical play and the pushback against the Lightning. In their 3 Stars of the Game, Dave looks at how far Hildeby has come in his development, the top line continuing to show improvement and Morgan Rielly making the most of his opportunity. To end the show, Mike and Dave have a discussion on William Nylander looking off and Bobby McMann in trouble with the NHL.

The Toronto Maple Leafs face a critical test as injuries to Joseph Woll and Anthony Stolarz add pressure to their goaltending depth. Can Dennis Hildeby anchor the net and keep the Leafs in contention? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti break down the gritty overtime loss to the Montreal Canadiens, Scott Laughton's old-time breakaway clapper, and other notable positives but also raise questions about the Leafs offensive execution. With the uncertainty around the health of the Leafs' goaltending, Mike and Dave wonder if they should look at veteran options. The hosts preview a pivotal Atlantic Division clash against the depleted Tampa Bay Lightning and debate whether the Leafs can capitalize on a shorthanded rival.

The Toronto Maple Leafs surge with a dominant win over the Carolina Hurricanes, but it comes at a cost as Joseph Woll exits with a concerning injury. Can the Leafs sustain their momentum with potential goaltending challenges ahead? Mike DiStefano and David Morassutti spotlight Matthew Knies’ electrifying two-way performance and Auston Matthews’ assertive form. The conversation breaks down the effectiveness of the “identity line,” Scott Laughton’s timely offensive spark, and Troy Stecher’s surprising impact as a blue line fixture. Goaltending depth steps into the spotlight with Dennis Hildeby poised to fill the void, while the Leafs’ upcoming clash against the Montreal Canadiens looms large in the playoff race.