Is Josh Safdie’s solo debut an absolute ace? On this episode of Mate Night, we’re doing a deep dive into the most anticipated A24 release of the year: Marty Supreme (2025).
We discuss everything from the staggering $70 million budget to Timothée Chalamet’s transformative and "unbelievable" performance as the legendary 1950s ping-pong hustler. Was it worth the hype, or did it miss the mark? We give our raw gut reactions before putting the film through the world-famous Mate Night Machine to calculate the one true score.
In this episode, we cover:
Marty Supreme Movie Review: Our honest thoughts on Josh Safdie’s direction.
Timothée Chalamet Analysis: Why this might be his most eccentric role yet.
The A24 Factor: How the studio’s highest budget film holds up on the big screen.
The Mate Night Machine: The final, definitive verdict on the film’s quality.
Whether you're a die-hard Safdie fan or just here for the Chalamet craze, join us as we break down the spin, the swerve, and the soul of this high-stakes drama.
Strap in, strap on, and let's find the one true score.
All About Eve (1950) — film podcast deep dive and review from Mate Night. We go behind the Broadway dressing-room doors: Bette Davis vs Anne Baxter, that legendary script, and whether this Oscar-winning classic really earns its “one of the greatest” reputation. Ambition, ageing, performance, gender politics and the film’s place in cinema history — what still lands, what creaks, and which bits fans are too kind about.
Wicked: For Good (2025) takes us back into the land of Oz — but this time things don’t quite add up. In this one-episode special, the Mate Night team explore why this massive finale feels like it’s on a completely different timeline than the iconic The Wizard of Oz (1939). We break down:
The character flips: Elphaba vs. the Wicked Witch, Glinda’s unexpected arc, the Wizard who can’t pick a personality
The plot explosions: Scarecrow on fire twice, slippers that teleport, and how the story only works if you ignore the original
The book origins: Gregory Maguire’s gritty novel that started it all, and how the musical and film diverge wildly
The parallel-universe theory: Why Wicked isn’t a prequel — it’s an entirely separate Oz
Our verdict: Fred’s take-down, Jambo’s defence, and whether fans of Oz should even bother
If you came out of Wicked: For Good scratching your head, thinking “This can’t fit the original” — you’re absolutely right. Tune in for the full breakdown, join the debate, and find out why sometimes the story you love needs a separate universe.
Subscribe to Mate Night for deep-dives, film debates, and podcast episodes every week.
Boogie Nights (1997) — film podcast deep dive and review from Mate Night. Paul Thomas Anderson’s porn industry epic gets the usual treatment: story, direction, performances, design, and whether it truly earns its classic status. Then we go off-set for the Burt Reynolds saga — the tension with Anderson, the almost-fight, firing his agent, and why he later distanced himself from the film.
One Battle After Another (2025) - film podcast review and deep dive from Mate Night. We pull apart Paul Thomas Anderson’s DiCaprio-led action thriller: politics, pacing, set-pieces, and whether it really deserves the “movie of the year” noise. Then we go back to Boogie Nights and the road not taken: DiCaprio nearly playing Dirk Diggler, choosing Titanic instead, and how that alternate timeline changes the way this new film feels.
Alien (1979) & Aliens (1986) - a deep dive double review from the Mate Night film podcast. We test Ridley Scott’s haunted-ship horror against James Cameron’s war-movie sequel: story, direction, performances, design, effects, score. Reputation vs reality, what truly holds up, and where the cracks show. Expect clear arguments, minimal spoilers, and a verdict that may upset both camps.
they're not actually film critics it just sounded better than film reviewers.
so it turns out the boys can read. they started the wheel of time - a 15 book long fantasy epic series. tune in to this mate night special to hear what they thought and also some other stuff.
ALSO
fred read the next book. poll below.
the boys were in for a shock when they tuned into Park Chan Wook's The Handmaiden, for both good and bad reasons. undoubtedly the most needlessly graphic scenes of an adult nature that have been committed to film
A clockwork orange. is it a masterpiece? or is it just a bit shit? tune in to find out what two random guys think.
Hot off its July 11 2025 theatrical debut, James Gunn’s long-awaited Superman reboot has already soared past $217 million worldwide in its opening weekend, kicking off the new DCU era with record-setting numbers.
In this episode we break down David Corenswet’s take on the Man of Steel, Rachel Brosnahan’s quick-witted Lois Lane, and Gunn’s brighter, hope-first tone—while weighing the polarised early reviews that range from raves about its screwball energy to jabs at “cluttered backstory” and “generic” plotting.
Join us for a spoiler-filled chat on whether this fresh start really delivers truth, justice, and a revitalised DC universe—or just another cape in the crowd.
The boys are back after a long summery break to review some of the blockbusters.
F1 movie released in theatres ... recently.. and just Jamie watched it so he's reporting back to Fred. Enjoy!
Join the boys for some more unprepared movie review antics on the Road to Cannes
Join the boys for some more unprepared movie review antics on the Road to Cannes
The boys return for more unprepared antics as they review more films on the road to Cannes!
The boys return for more unprepared antics as they review more films on the road to Cannes!
Episode Description: The Minecraft Movie (2025)
In this episode of Mate Night, we dig into The Minecraft Movie (2025), the long-awaited cinematic adaptation of the global gaming phenomenon. Directed by Jared Hess and starring Jason Momoa, the film promised a bold, blocky adventure—but with mixed early reactions, we’re asking: did it mine gold or hit bedrock?
Episode Highlights:
First Impressions: We share our gut reactions to Minecraft’s leap from console to cinema—did it build something worth watching?
Rating Categories: We evaluate the film across our core criteria:
Our Engagement
Story Innovation
Character Depth
Dialogue Impact
Performances
Visual Ambiance
Sound Intensity
Cultural Impact
Featured Segments:
We look back at the checquered history of production on this film. How it went through 3 directors and 2 production studios before finally making it to theatres. Over a decade after the initial announcement!
Final Score:
Does it earn a spot among the best game-to-film adaptations, or will it sink into the void? Our unique Mate Night scoring system delivers the verdict.
Why Listen?
Whether you’re a lifelong Minecraft fan or just curious about how they turned building blocks into a blockbuster, this episode breaks it all down—one pixel at a time.
In this spoiler-heavy podcast clip, we dive deep into the new hit TV series Adolescence, one of the most talked-about British dramas of the year. Is Adolescence a gripping, character-driven masterclass—or is it just another self-important BBC drama pretending to be profound? We couldn’t agree, and things got heated.Fred and I go head-to-head over everything: the show’s pacing, whether the final episode ruins the whole thing, Stephen Graham’s performance, and the use (or misuse) of bold stylistic choices like the continuous one-shot format. There’s a lot of praise out there for Adolescence, but not everyone’s buying the hype—and that’s exactly what led to this row.If you’ve watched Adolescence or you’re thinking about it, this is the conversation you didn’t know you needed. We’ll help you work out if it’s worth your time. We cover gut reactions, narrative structure, character arcs, thematic ambition, and whether it sticks the landing. Spoiler alert: we land on very different scores.Whether you're here for a review, a breakdown, or to hear two best mates absolutely tear each other apart over prestige TV—you're in the right place.👇 Let us know in the comments what you thought of Adolescence. Did the final episode ruin it for you too?
In this episode, we delve into Wicked (2024), the highly anticipated film adaptation of the beloved musical, directed by Jon M. Chu. Known for his visually stunning direction, Chu brings the magical land of Oz to life like never before.
Episode Highlights:
First Impressions: We share our initial reactions to Chu’s interpretation of this Broadway classic and how it balances the beloved source material with fresh cinematic elements.
Rating Categories: We break down the film across key categories:
Featured Segments:
Final Score:
We compare Wicked (2024) to other musical adaptations and discuss its place in the pantheon of great cinematic musicals.
Why Listen?
Join us as we journey through the emerald green landscapes of Oz, exploring friendship, rebellion, and the magic of Wicked. Whether you're a die-hard musical theater fan or a casual viewer, our discussion is sure to entertain and inform!
Reviewing The IMDb top 250 in Alphabetical Order Until Someone Invites Us to Cannes. This is 12 Angry Men.
Join us as we dive into the world of cinema with our series, "The Road to Cannes." Each episode includes:
🎬 Movie Reviews: In-depth analysis and fresh takes on each film.🎥 Unearthed Stories: Discovering hidden gems and untold narratives behind the scenes.💭 Provocative Questions: Engaging our audience with thought-provoking queries about the films.
Our Schedule:📅 Podcasts: Wednesdays and Sundays at 5 p.m. (UK) / 9 a.m. (PST)📅 YouTube Videos: Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays, and Sundays at 5 p.m. (UK) / 9 a.m. (PST)