We’ve reached the end of Season 2, which means it’s time to step back, look at the big picture, and rank, roast, and reminisce. In this recap episode of Something Witchy, we break down our overall thoughts on Season 2 of Sabrina the Teenage Witch—from our top three episodes to our least favorite installment and overall season rating. We dig into the season-long story arc, debate favorite and least favorite new characters, and crown the best montage of the season. Then it’s time to turn things over to you! We answer listener questions from Reddit and Instagram, including which episodes we’re most excited to cover in the future, thoughts on the infamous duck costume from “A River of Candy Corn Runs Through It,” and which characters deserved more—or less—screen time. To round things out, we play a chaotic round of blind ranking with questions like who we’d trust with a shared bank account and who we’d let babysit our most precious belongings. Plus, Skye surprises Laura with a game of their own. It’s a packed recap full of opinions, laughs, and listener love—thanks for spending Season 2 with us.

In the Season 2 finale of Sabrina the Teenage Witch, everything comes crashing down at once—and we’re breaking it all down on Something Witchy. In Mom vs. Magic, Sabrina finds herself juggling two very big problems: Harvey and Dashiell unexpectedly meet and demand she choose between them, and the Witches’ Council discovers she’s secretly contacted her mother, triggering a devastating ultimatum. With only 12 hours to decide between keeping her magic or ever seeing her mom again, Sabrina faces the hardest choice of her life. Meanwhile, Salem’s mother comes for a surprise visit (and doesn’t know he’s a cat), and Zelda and Hilda discover—once and for all—who their mother’s actual favorite child is. Plus: this week’s question of the week—what memorable gifts have YOU given your mom?

It’s the Season 2 penultimate episode, and Sabrina’s latest magical misstep brings us straight into intergalactic chaos. In Rumor Mill, Sabrina takes a shortcut on her Other Realm community service assignment after being recruited by Bobby Calzone to work at the literal rumor mill—where gossip isn’t just entertaining, it’s magically consequential. Unfortunately, she and returning guest Dashiell get a little too carried away writing rumors about people they actually know… and suddenly everything becomes real in Westbridge. That means Libby gets evicted, Mr. Kraft and Ms. Quick become a PDA-heavy couple, Salem becomes a full-blown mob boss, Harvey is mysteriously pregnant, and the Spellman aunt road trip ends with a full-on UFO abduction. With the Quizmaster’s job on the line and Calzone causing chaos behind the scenes, Sabrina is forced to clean up her magical mess the hard way—or at least the most humiliating way. We also chat about this week’s Question of the Week: Do we believe in aliens or UFOs? Spoiler: We have thoughts.

This week on Something Witchy, we're keeping things cozy, chaotic, and deliciously on-theme with a special Thanksgiving mini-sode!  Instead of our usual deep-dives, Laura and Skye sit down to assign Sabrina the Teenage Witch characters to classic Thanksgiving family archetypes—because who among us hasn’t met a Libby-style cousin, a Salem-energy meddling uncle, or a Hilda-level chaotic relative? We kept this one short so we (and hopefully you!) can spend time with loved ones, enjoy rest, good food, or just a well-earned break. Whether you celebrate Thanksgiving or not, we are so grateful for everyone who listens, supports, and chats with us—especially as we just passed 10,000 downloads! Thank you for being part of this witchy little home we're building. Take a seat at the Spellman table with us, enjoy the family chaos from a safe distance, and we’ll be back to regular episodes soon!

This week on Something Witchy, we’re diving into one of the most chaotic Season 2 episodes yet: “Sabrina’s Choice.” When Sabrina pits Hilda and Zelda against each other one too many times, the aunts decide to split up—and suddenly Sabrina has to choose which aunt she’ll live with. From floating backpacks and forbidden Lisa Loeb concerts to the horrors of house-divided living, Sabrina faces every teen witch’s worst nightmare: consequences.   We walk through the iconic guest appearances from RuPaul and the Kenan & Kel duo, the absolutely unhinged “what-if” future timelines (Libby’s baby, anyone?), Salem’s unwavering commitment to dramatic flair, and the Spellmans’ experimental approach to parenting. We also break down the aunts’ elaborate ruse, the Witch Judge’s unexpected makeover career, and why this entire episode feels like a fever dream in the best possible way.   Join us for messy houses, science experiments gone rogue, chaotic hairstyles, and the most dramatic family therapy session the Other Realm has ever seen.

It’s field trip week on Something Witchy! Sabrina and the Westbridge crew head to Disney World, where magic and mayhem go hand-in-hand. When Sabrina’s latest witch’s license test requires her to brew an animal transformation potion, things take a turn for the wild—literally—after Valerie and Libby end up as zebras roaming Animal Kingdom. Meanwhile, Hilda and Zelda discover a “prehistoric” surprise on their paleontology excursion, and Salem lives his best resort life. In this episode, Laura and Skye talk Disney parks (and which rides are actually worth the wait), TGIF’s obsession with crossover trips, and our love for Disney cats.

In Season 2, Episode 22 of Sabrina the Teenage Witch, “Quiz Show,” Sabrina finally learns the importance of her Quizmaster — but only after she accidentally gets him fired. While Zelda returns to the classroom as a substitute chemistry teacher (and Libby might actually learn something?!), Sabrina struggles to master her elemental magic, balance her attitude, and untangle her magical mentorship drama. Plus: we talk about things that finally “clicked” for us, Zelda’s potential (or lack thereof) as a teacher, and the importance of a good montage.

In Fear Strikes Up a Conversation (Season 2, Episode 21), Sabrina tries to zap away her fear of public speaking—but when her fear literally comes to life and starts haunting her classmates, chaos (and comedy) ensues. Meanwhile, Zelda pushes herself to the brink of madness preparing for a symposium, Hilda throws a luau intervention, and Salem just wants someone to remember to feed him. Laura and Skye break down the episode’s creative take on anxiety, public speaking nightmares, and why facing your fears—witch or mortal—is never as easy as zapping them away.

Life got the better of us this week, so we brewed up something short, spooky, and full of laughs for Halloween! In this mini-sode, Skye hosts a game of Monster Mash—assigning iconic Sabrina the Teenage Witch characters to classic monsters (because obviously someone has Dracula energy). Then, Laura takes over with a round of This or Witch, where we make the tough choices every witch faces—broomstick or vacuum? Cauldron or coffee? It’s a quick, cozy, chaotic Halloween treat with all the Something Witchy humor you know and love.

This week on Something Witchy, Laura and Skye rewatch Sabrina the Teenage Witch Season 2, Episode 20: “My Nightmare, the Car.” Sabrina finally gets the car she’s been begging for — but, in true Other Realm fashion, it’s a little more talkative (and possessive) than she bargained for. As Sabrina and Valerie’s car-sharing arrangement crashes and burns, chaos hits the Spellman house when a magical audit goes wrong and the family accountant goes rogue. Plus, our hosts detour into discussions about French tacos, their first cars, and whether halberds are underrated as a form of self-defense.

Things are getting unstable in Westbridge—literally! In Season 2, Episode 19: “When Teens Collide,” a burst of sunspots causes chaos in the mortal and witch worlds alike. Sabrina and Libby accidentally swap personalities, turning Sabrina into the school’s new mean girl and Libby into… a sweetheart?! Meanwhile, the aunts deal with a black hole in the kitchen sink, a rogue string trio, and yet another trial in the Other Realm. Join us as Laura and Skye unpack this chaotic episode, from Sabrina’s power trip to Salem’s reluctant hero moment.

When Harvey signs Sabrina, Valerie, and himself up for a battle of the bands, there’s just one small problem: they can’t actually play. Desperate not to lose to Libby and the cheerleaders, Sabrina brews up some bottled talent to give them an edge. The spell works a little too well, though, and soon egos and friendships are on the line. Meanwhile, Hilda takes a gig as a fiddler, Zelda faces off with a rival scientist, and Salem enjoys the drama from the sidelines. Oh, and did we mention the Backstreet Boys stop by?

It’s Valentine’s season in Westbridge, and love is in the air—sort of. In Sabrina the Teenage Witch Season 2, Episode 17, “The Equalizer,” Sabrina learns that bending the rules of magic comes with a price when Roland the troll returns as a magical “Equalizer” and literally steals her heart. Meanwhile, Cupid is down bad after heartbreak, Zelda and Hilda scramble for dates to the school dance, and Mr. Kraft can’t resist stirring up trouble. We unpack the chaos of magical consequences, talk about the surprisingly sweet moments, and debate just how many times Roland needs to be told “no.”

In Sabrina and the Beanstalk (Season 2, Episode 16), Sabrina’s last-minute spellwork grows way out of control when a beanstalk sprouts in the Spellman yard, Harvey gets kidnapped by a wicked witch (guest star Shelley Long), and the whole thing turns into a magical mess straight out of a fairy tale. Laura and Skye dig into the episode’s chaos, from Salem’s fear of heights to why Harvey really needs to stop eating suspicious food at Sabrina’s house. Along the way, the conversation takes a few turns of its own—like how zoos decide on breeding matches for animals, and why Laura might just murder Skye over a debate about fry sauce.

This week on Something Witchy, we dive into Sabrina the Teenage Witch Season 2, Episode 15, “Finger Lickin’ Flu.” When Sabrina catches a magical flu in her pointing finger, her powers accidentally transfer to Mrs. Quick—who wastes no time zapping chaos through Westbridge and even turns Mr. Kraft into a chimpanzee. We break down the episode’s wild physical comedy, Salem’s over-the-top quest for attention, and how this story gives Mrs. Quick a rare spotlight.

It’s time for another Sabrina vs. Libby showdown—this time with a magical twist. When Sabrina tries to use a spell to keep Libby at arm’s length, it backfires spectacularly, leaving the two magically tethered together and, eventually, turning Libby into a literal jigsaw puzzle. To set things right, Sabrina has to piece Libby back together—literally and figuratively—while discovering some surprising truths about her frenemy’s life. Meanwhile, Hilda and Salem’s get-rich-quick scheme with Zelda’s “miracle” formula spirals out of control, leading to slime, sibling squabbles, and toaster chaos. Join us as we break down the puzzles, the lessons in compassion, and the float that proves democracy really is fragile.

This week we’re diving into Little Big Kraft (Season 2, Ep. 13), where Sabrina decides that Mr. Kraft is way too uptight and whips up a potion to make him act younger. What starts as a harmless prank quickly spirals when a little caffeine turns the spell into chaos, and suddenly the halls of Westbridge High are falling apart under the “leadership” of a childlike vice principal. Meanwhile, Hilda finds herself falling even harder for Kraft in his youthful state, and Zelda has to remind Sabrina—again—why you don’t mess with people’s personalities.

It’s Christmas in Westbridge, and Sabrina is learning the hard way that the holiday season isn’t just about presents. In Season 2, Episode 12, Sabrina Claus, our favorite teenage witch comes down with a magical case of “ego-titis” and ends up face-to-face with none other than Santa himself—though he goes by Bob (played by Cheers’ John Ratzenberger). When Bob gets injured, Sabrina has to fill in and take on the role of delivering Christmas magic to the world, whether she’s ready or not. We dig into Sabrina’s struggle to rediscover the true meaning of Christmas, the sheer chaos of the Spellman holiday décor, Salem’s endless holiday snark, and a very special musical cameo from Johnny Mathis. Plus, we talk about the wild clothing options, the episode’s surprising shout out to Utah, and how we still don't know where Sabrina and Harvey's relationship is.

In Season 2 Episode 11 "Oh What a Tangled Spell She Weaves," Sabrina’s sloppy spellcasting spirals out of control—turning antique cabinets brand new, shrinking Salem into a kitten, and even sending her aunts straight into Merlin’s castle. While Valerie gets a magical efficiency boost at her new pizza job and Harvey undergoes a few unintended changes of his own, Sabrina learns the hard way that vague incantations have very real consequences. With no “undo” spells to save her, she has to clean up the chaos before her friends freeze, burn, or get stuck in medieval times forever.

It’s Friday the 13th, and Sabrina finally gets the green light to do what she’s been dying to try: tell her friends she’s a witch! In this episode, we talk through all the chaos that ensues when Valerie and Harvey get a full day in the know—complete with magic tickets, a trip to the Other Realm’s Mortal Day Festival, and celebrity cameos from Drew Carey and Mark Langston. We also dig into the risks of revealing your secrets, Salem’s reign of terror, and why Libby probably needs serious therapy after everything she’s seen. Plus, we marvel at magic corn dogs, posters in the school hallway, and a whole lot of bat breath. Will Sabrina regret spilling the beans? Let’s find out.